The 2007 Navteq LBS challenge... Putting Location-Based services On The Map!
Written by Glenn Letham
Friday, 06 April 2007
At CTIA Wireless 2007 in Orlando, Florida there was no doubt that LBS was hot…
plain and simple. Perhaps it’s not the killer app [yet]; however, it is one hot
topic at the show with LBS on the tongues of many and LBS at the center of many
discussions. To reinforce just how hot LBS is, Navteq once again took center stage
announcing the winners of this year’s LBS Challenge.
Congratulations goes out to Comvue Media Inc (Vancouver, BC) for their PocketCaster™
GPS application which took top honors in the competition and walked away with
$50K in cash (and $10k for winning the Business Application category) +$100k in
Navteq data licenses. The application is designed to take advantage of camera
phones (video) with integrated GPS capabilities (like the new Nokia N95). Simply
put, the app enables simple, one-button mobile web casting where the user can
stream video live to a web server while the application also embeds data, time,
and geopositioning information into the video stream. The user’s location can
be tracked and viewed dynamically on a mashup (like a Google map) or with Navteq
data while the video is streaming and the user location is continually updated.
Comvue is the developer of the popular Comvue PocketCaster application, enabling
users to stream live video to websites, blogs, or other web apps. See http://www.comvu.com/
The "GISuser guys" get the skinny on the winning application from ComVu
In my mind, from what I saw and heard during the week, LBS is truly hot and up-and-coming...
perhaps its not THE “killer app” but there’s no question, LBS is indeed a hot
topic… think otherwise and you’re out to lunch! On the show floor, location-enabled
apps and solutions were everywhere. Visiting booths from the likes of Tele Atlas,
Autodesk, ESRI, and even Nokia and you were presented with material and information
about their developer programs – all offering developers tools, APIs, and SDKs
to help get up and running with location-based services and application. At the
LBS Challenge there were some 344 developer entries this year – that’s up from
256 at last year’s Challenge! At a developer panel I attended with several major
US carriers being represented the following question was asked to the panel… “What
are the hot enterprise applications in demand”? The rep from Verizon Wireless
quickly responded without hesitation… LBS.
Getting back to the LBS Challenge, this recent event marks the 4th year that
the popular event has taken place, with Winston Guillory, Navteq Senior VP of
Consumer & Enterprise acting as host and MC for the event. Prior to announcing
the winners, Guillory provide a brief update on the company’s (Navteq) role in
the LBS space. To date the company boasts users in some 60 countries on 6 continents,
they have more than 600 geographic analysts driving the roads in an effort to
update and maintain the company’s massive database – each drive crew collects
data updates the roads database with some 200 attributes. Perhaps most important
though, are the company’s 90 million+ consumer touch points every day! That’s
right; 90 million people touch and use Navteq data in some form each and every
day. Guillory attributes the company’s swelling usage to a number of reasons,
including the usage of LBS applications on many different devices (not just limited
to PDAs any longer), the explosive, viral use of LBS application, and perhaps
most important, the key role that maps and location content play in new applications.
LBS applications are typically serving several key market segments; these can
be categorized as navigation, entertainment, social networks, and business – coincidentally
(or not) the LBS Challenge recognizes winners for creating compelling applications
in each of these 4 segments.
A little more on the state of the LBS industry:
Consumer usage of LBS-enabled apps is growing rapidly, with the most popular
use being maps and directions, location search, nearby entertainment location,
and perhaps the most highly anticipated segment (as seen and heard at the CTIA
conference) LBS gaming. Driving the uptake of Location services are the growing
number of GPS-enabled phones, with GSM devices like the Nokia N95 and 6610 “navigator”
now penetrating the space (finally). The ever increasing important of local search
(i.e. what’s near me) as well ass community and content sharing is also propelling
the demand and usage of location in the mobile arena – think about it. Just imagine
what you can do when your cell phone knows exactly where you are and then shares
that location with applications and services!
Back to the Challenge
Marc Naddell, Navteq VP noted that this years LBS challenge had 344 application
developers registered. Of interest, roughly one third of the developers were from
each of the 3 major Global market regions, EMEA, Asia Pacific, and North America.
Navteq’s reason for hosting the competition is quite simple… easing the development
burden placed on developers and driving the commercialization of applications
– indeed it appears that that have done just that. The contest was open to any
developer; provide that their submitted application is not yet commercially available.
The bait was a prize pool valued at roughly $2 million.
Registration is up, way up… again!
Registration has grown steadily over the past 4 years:
2007 – 344
2006/05 – 256
2004/05 – 182
2003/04 – 42
No surprise that registration has grown steadily, particularly when you consider
that maps and directions currently account for roughly 33% of mobile application
downloads by revenue. Consumer usage and consumption of location-aware applications
has grown steadily with directions, location search, nearby entertainment finders,
and LBS gaming are all on the upswing and growing in popularity. Much of the driving
force for the popularity of Location-aware apps is the growing number of GPS-enabled
devices coming to market. Additionally, the popularity of local search and community
content sharing on the Internet has been viral and spread the demand to the mobile
space.
Contest Judging & the Winners
Judging is done by a group of mobile industry executives from leading names like
Nokia, AT&T, Bain Capital, Helio, Motorola, and Sprint. Applications were
judged in 4 categories: Business Apps, Entertainment & Leisure, Navigation,
and Social Networking.
The overall LBS Challenge winner was selected from the following group of semi-finalists
– 4 from each category:
Business Apps:
- MRewards – developed by Astroleap, this application rewards consumers for their
use of directional data. www.astroleap.com - PocketCaster GPS (ComVu Media Inc) – designed to enable quick, one button mobile
webcasting, encouraging the consumption of photos and videos from camera phones.
Video is streamed and viewed dynamically on a map display. www.comvu.com – Winning Application in the Business Category
- LBSNow is an application that shows users their proximity to businesses of
services – www.lbsnow.com - Mobile GPS home and apartment search from Smarter Agent is a clever application
that enables users to search for home listings using their cell phone. See www.smarteragent.com
Entertainment & Leisure
- GeoChief from TikGames enables players to create blogs, track routes, and navigate.
Powered by Autodesk - See www.tikgames.com – Winning app in the Entertainment & Leisure Category - Location-aware M-Commerce platform is for users who need to find, reserve,
and purchase travel and entertainment services. Powered by Openwave - See www.w-planit.com - Wuh-sup combines personal preferences with location to provide a mobile concierge
service to users. Search, reference, and build agendas. Powered by deCarta. See
www.wuh-sup.com - Wall Street Fighter from YDreams Entertainment puts you in a world of business
for an exciting location-based game experience. Powered by Knowledgeware. See
www.ydreams.com
Navigation
- Ioto is an LBS solution for selling transportation services between POIs. Self-powered
app, see www.ioto.com - Parkwhiz provides users with mobile parking information. Users can get location-aware
information on parking like availability, directions, hours, prices, and more.
Powered by Autodesk, see www.parkwhiz.com - Winning application in the Navigation category
- SpotKask is a very clever solution from 1023software powered by deCarta. SpotKast
will push helpful, relevant information to your phone based on your present location.
Wherever you are, have instant access to a local directory of recommended businesses.
Wonder if any web sites or blogs have anything to say about where you are standing?
See SpotKast.com or www.ten23software.com - Car Finder, an Autodesk powered solution from Zeetoo Inc. Never get lost in
that parking lot again! This application stores your vehicles location on your
mobile device. When you press the “unlock” button when you return near your vehicle
directions will be sent to your phone to guide you to the vehicle’s exact location…
cool, no more walking aimlessly around the West lot at DIA searching for my car!
Social Networking Category
- Beacon is an ESRI –powered solution from duzine.com LLC. This application automatically
records and map’s the user’s location. On a website users can provide additional
details about themselves and even publish their locations to a MySpace account,
blog, upload photos and more. See www.dusine.com - Milogo from Eloquor is another Autodesk-powered application. This solution
acts as a friend-finder service and works across wireless carriers. The application
serves Navteq maps and shows the location of friends and colleagues on the user’s
cell phone. Once connected the user can communicate with the friend via txt. See
www.elloqor.com - Activepilot from Jentro Technologies GmbH is powered by PTV. This application,
supporting most Java phones, acts as a sensor for generating traffic flow information
through its users. See www.jentro.com – activepilot was selected as the winner of the Social networking category - Loopt is a very slick friend-finder app powered by deCarta. Using this solution,
users can track their friend’s location on maps right from their mobile handset.
It also enables users to share messages and send auto notification updates when
a friend is nearby.
Judging was conducted by a diverse group of mobile industry professionals. The
criteria for selection was the bundling of unique functionality and features as
well as special attention being paid to the ease of use – it should be noted that
“ease of use” has been frequently billed at this year’s CTIA as being the new
“killer app”.. Clearly it is vital for the success of any mobile application.
ComVu developers are presented with the Cheque for their Grand Prize winning
application
Glenn’s LBS Challenge Selections & Special Recognition
So what did I think was cool? Well, here’s a few of my own personal “awards”
and special recognition:
- Coolest name… definitely Wuh-Sup… brings back memories of the old beer commercial doesn’t
it?
- Cool Geotagging – no doubt about it, loopt is all about social networking, however, I love the
way the app enables users to geotag and share digital photos… I can’t get enough
use out of my camera phone and this kind of app will make using it even better.
- Opportunity to extend application… ParkWhiz definitely fills a demand, however, imagine this (especially you parents)…
how about Park & whiz? Imagine an LBS-centric solution that not only helps
you locate parking but also points you to convenient and clean restrooms… sounds
like a winner to me!
- Coolest LBS gadget… Zeetoo (the guys who developed the “key fob” that helps you locate your parked
vehicle also have a very slick wireless controller (think joystick) that communicates
with your mobile via Bluetooth. Use the gadget to navigate apps running on your
device or as a joystick for mobile games… pretty clever!
- Best way to drive ARPU... no doubt the winning app. – PocketCaster GPS. With so many camera-enabled
smart phones in use users are craving uses beyond simply uploading their youTube
videos. This app takes mobile video streaming to a whole new level… watching your
video stream on top of a map is just the icing on the cake. Imagine watching your
fiend’s video from the ski slope thousands of miles away… add to that you see
their track laid on top of a map… I love it!
- Coolest app… there’s no question in my mind; I was “wowed” by SpotKast from 1023software.
I know it runs on Blackberry (which I don’t own); however, the concept is way
cool and was a very clever and intuitive way to keep you informed of location-aware
news and updates. Particularly cool was their “SpotPost” concept. Users can leave
notes (or whatever they want... files, images, MP3s, or ??) and the post is geocoded
to your location. Imagine reading restaurant reviews while you stand in line waiting
for that little electronic coaster to light up… WOW!
- LBS M.I.A, no doubt this one goes to Openwave… was there actually anyone from Openwave
present at the LBS Challenge? If there was you were pretty discrete. Too bad since
there was several openwave=powered apps in the finals including the winning application
from ComVu Media. The table stand with your name and empty literature holder was
a visible oops.
- Honorable Mention... Navteq. For getting a larger room this year!
Navteq is clearly focused on easing the development burdens placed on developers
of location-based services. Their commitment to the LBS Challenge has helped drive
the commercialization of LBS. Congratulations to Navteq, the Challenge sponsors,
and to all the participants.
I can’t wait for the next LBS Challenge… perhaps I’ll get to the Euro Challenge
next year at 3GSM and maybe the north American Challenge will see 500 entries.
Regardless, the Navteq LBS Challenge has done more for developers and carriers
than anything I can think of in recent years. The real prizes yet to be dolled
out include venture capital funding and lucrative contracts from the carriers…
no doubt we’ll be reading news on these topics in the near future – follow LBSzone.com
for the latest news updates from companies chasing the LBS carrot.
Some “LBS” Observations and relevant industry comments made at CTIA:
CTIA Wireless 2007 – there’s no doubt about it, content is still king… however,
simplicity and ease of use are indeed “the killer app”. That was the message presented
in sessions, demonstrations, panel discussions, and meetings at North America’s
recent wireless industry convention. Some of the key impressions I took away from
the event include the following:
mobile content is king and the industry (and users) are craving more mobile content
– in particular entertainment.
Application developers have plenty of opportunities, although the competition
is brisk. Simple to use, intuitive applications are what people want. Make it
functional, entertaining, useful, and simple.
Location-based services and applications are hot and in demand. Think about it,
there were more than 340 entries in this year’s North American LBS Challenge.
Looking to get your LBS app on a device? Think social networking, community building,
entertainment, and gaming… these appear to be the LBS services that are of greatest
interest (to carriers and end users)
GPS-enabled devices are coming on strong.
Developing applications for a variety of handsets, operating systems, and languages
is still a challenge. It’s still quite amazing to see many applications that have
been created to run solely on one application or even one device.
LBSChallenge Global Sponsor, Nokia announced the N95 just prior to the CTIA event. The device ships with integrated GPS and kick's
off Nokia's commitment to location-enabled devices. 5 MB digital camera, high
quality video, integrated GPS, spanky webbrowsing, and much more. Here's some
specs from Nokia - Dual slide functionality, 5 megapixel camera, Carl Zeiss optics,
DVD-like video, connect wirelessly to the internet, integral GPS & mapping
functionality, 2.6" display, media player, personalize your device with downloadable
applications, widgets and RSS feeds - devices like this will drive the uptake of LBS... no doubt!
These are but a few of the topics that stuck out in my mind after taking in 3
days at CTIA. Here are more samplings of items that got my attention and may get
you thinking about the direction you want to take as you develop apps and services
for the mobile space heading into 2008:
China – explosive usage – 25 new customers every second - 30% of cellphone users
in China use smartphones.. this compares to about 7% in the USA!
US usage at about 75%
93% of mobile users surveyed by mywireless.org are satisfied with current service
provider
68% believe government regulation on wireless will make services more costly
The new killer app… ease of use. Bringing together the 3 screens.
Demand for speed and data. Usage of data apps for business has soared $7.2 B
usage in 2006… data usage is exploding. Today 1 in 5 users uses data. 45% of youth
are mobile data users.
Mobile banking is also coming on and is in high demand.
40% of population frequently looks for directions on web
Note: local search is expected to grow 282% in next 5 years. Great as only 15%
of cell phone users use data services.
A tip to Developers, avoid navigation services (saturated) maybe look at social
networking or location-based games as an option.
Location isn’t a service, it’s a service enabler.
To stay informed about the LBS Challenge and future contests see www.lbschallenge.com
For LBS related technology news and annoucnements see www.LBSzone.com
Mobile Technology Blogs, News, and RSS Feeds... Looking for more news, tips, commentary, and blogger discussions? Check out
these excellent feeds for more on wireless technologies and mobile application
development. Got a feed to share? Please tell us about it...
SymbianOne Sponsored Links and Events
The Future of LBS Seminar - Wavefront presents to the Pacific NW developer community: NAVTEQ Executive Breakfast Seminar: "The Future of LBS" Tuesday, September 30, 2008 7:45 - 9:00 AM (PST)
The European Navigation Event, October 7th and 8th 2008... where retail meets industry - The fourth edition of the No. 1 European Navigation Event will take place in the inspiring environment of the High Tech Campus in Eindhoven, The Netherlands.
Smartphone Show, 21-22 October 2008, Earls Court 2, London - The 10th annual Smartphone Show promises to be the best ever with more opportunities to see innovative technology in action and meet the key personnel driving it.
iPhone Live - November 18, San Jose, CA - iPhoneLive is the new O'Reilly conference for iPhone developers, entrepreneurs, and enthusiasts, focusing on both the business and development issues surrounding the iPhone platform.
Nokia World 2008, Barcelona Spain - With thought-provoking seminars, informed keynote speakers and a wide range of interactive experiences, Nokia World 08 can inspire anyone and everyone with an active interest in the business of mobility. December 2-3, 2008
LBSZone.com - for developers interested in mobile location-based services Geospatial & LBS News - Stay abreast of geospatial technologies with daily updates